A Cayman sunrise. Photo by Eziethamae “Zeta” Bodden

This gorgeous sunrise was captured by regular reader of The Cayman Reporter, Eziethamae “Zeta” Bodden on Saturday 21 May at 6am as she was on her way to the Rotaract Blue Fred Speirs 5K, which raised funds for scholarships in vocational training for local youth.

“As I reached the bridge on West Bay Road the sun was coming up behind the clouds,” Ms Bodden said. The Cayman Reporter welcomes photos sent in by our readers. Please send your favourite images to news@caymanreporter.com along with the name of the photographer and the date the photo was taken.

The post Smile with the rising sun appeared first on The Cayman Reporter.

Some 19 vendors at West Bay Public Beach are facing ejection as the deadline for warning notices from the Department of Commerce and Investment (DCI) to get licensed to sell or close up shop draws nearer.

Government is actively considering the creation of a vending area to accommodate the near 19 vendors facing ejection from West Bay Public Beach after the Department of Commerce and Investment (DCI) served warning notices on them.

Tourism Councillor Joseph Hew, speaking with The Cayman Reporter on the issue last week, said a joint ministerial team was set up to address the vending situation on the beach.

He assured that a permanent solution is being pursued by the team, one that will facilitate the vendors and assist in regulating and licensing them as required by the law.

The councillor said there are a number of proposed solutions including the creation of a designated vending area.

“We are looking at some infrastructure changes in West Bay, of course those would require planning approvals and moving of the roads etc to give extra space. We are looking at the public beach to try and set up a vendor area that they would be confined to and that (area). We could actually do a peppercorn lease and they would therefore be able to get the trade and business license to actually operate within that area,” the councillor explained.

He said the group, which consists of Tourism Ministry officials, DCI personnel, along with Department of Environmental Health, is trying to figure out the best solution.

“Now we are working with the vendors, working along with DCI to see how quickly we can get these folks regulated, get them licensed and also have to identify an area that they can set up because the DCI or the Trade and Business Licensing Board cannot issue a trade and business license for someone to operate on government property,” he stressed.

Opposition Leader Hon McKeeva Bush, addressing the issue on Radio Cayman’s For the Record talk show with Orrett “OC” Connor on Friday 20 May), said a structured and more humane approach must be adopted when dealing with the vendors at West Bay Public Beach as they are poor people seeking to earn an honest living.

Last week the vendors were served warning notices DCI to get licensed to sell or close up shop. The vendors claimed that they are unable to pay the fees being requested and have called for leniency from the DCI. The notices given to the vendors stated that “failure to comply with this notice can result in the issuance of ticketable fines under section 35 of the law and action may be taken against you.”

Mr Hew agreed that the vendors’ situation is not an ideal scenario, but he maintained that the law has to be enforced.

“We are working on a solution, we are trying our best to help get them all regulated so then they do not have to be worried about it again. They just comply and pay their fees and they are there and they are regulated,” Mr Hew contended.

The problem was growing, he said, as he pointed out that an audit last summer found nine vendors and a subsequent check in November found 15 vendors.

“Between then and more recently there were 19 vendors. It was something that was continuing to grow,” he said.

He said the situation as compounded by reports of harassment of tourists by aggressive vendors, as well as, “many, many reports of police having to go there for fights, for violence etc. We had reports of alcohol sales, illegal drugs sales.”

Added to this, he said, there was pressure from the private sector and the neighbours questioning what was being done about the situation.

He said something had to be done about the situation at the beach, not only for vendors but for Cayman’s reputation as well.

“If we continued down the road we were going, we only need one incident to happen and have the cruise lines pull out and we have seen that in other Caribbean islands. Then no one will have a job and they still will not make any money and the effect of that would be more long term,” Mr Hew contended.

He said the vendors do have options such as relocating to the craft market in George Town and the new market in Bodden Town.

“We do have the opportunity to expand (George Town craft market) if persons want to become part of the craft market at the top of Boilers Road. If we can get persons moving there and we can create a bigger craft market there I am certain that more tourists would go there. It is a site, an attraction,” he added.

The post Gov’t mulls trade area for West Bay vendors appeared first on The Cayman Reporter.

Bodden:Children Law under constant review

Minister of Community Affairs, Youth and Sports Hon Osborne Bodden says his ministry and the Department of Children and Family Service (DCFS) are constantly reviewing the Children Law (2012 Revision) which is a critical legislation to safeguard children of these Islands. This as he commented on the rising numbers of offences relating to children the latest of which occurred last week with the court appearance of a Jamaican national allegedly held with more than 1000 indecent images of children.

Minister of Community Affairs, Youth and Sports Hon Osborne Bodden has taken note of the rising numbers of child abuse cases being highlighted in recent months.

This as he said his ministry and the Department of Children and Family Service (DCFS) are constantly reviewing the Children Law (2012 Revision) “which is a critical legislation to safeguard children of these Islands.”

Mr Bodden made the comment as he addressed the rising numbers of offences relating to children in Cayman, the latest of which occurred last week with the court appearance of Jamaican national Travorne Daley who allegedly had more than 1000 indecent images of children on his computer and phone.

The Minister said at present there is an ongoing dialogue between the relevant agencies with regard to reviewing local legislationand how it deals with perpetrators of child abuse.

“Whilst the Ministry and DCFS support harsher penalties, we are also mindful that a holistic approach to both the perpetrator and the victim would be more beneficial to the community that is reducing risk factors and increasing protective factors for children in our community. It is necessary to also ensure that perpetrators receive appropriate treatment and therapy to prevent them from re-offending upon their release from prison,” he stressed.

He added that retribution for perpetrators, legislation for sentencing in such instances is dealt with under the Penal Code.

On Monday (23 May) Mr Daley, 24, was refused bail when he appeared in court on ten charges relating to the possession of more than a thousand indecent images of children and one charge of distribution of an image of a child.

The 24 year old Jamaican was remanded into custody. According to media reports Mr Daley was arrested by detectives in Cayman after US authorities passed on information on his alleged activities. Police reportedly found more than 1,000 images and more than 100 videos after his cell phone and lap top were seized.

Mr Bodden assured that provisions are in place within his ministry to address such cases as well as those involving the abuse of children.

“The Department of Children and Family Service (DCFS) is mandated to investigate all forms of child abuse including that of sexual abuse. Section 32A of the Children Law (2012 Revision), indicates that professionals who work with children are mandated to report child abuse to DCFS. The DCFS and the Royal Cayman Islands Police Service (RCIPS)- Family Support Unit (FSU) work collaboratively in investigating child abuse matters,” he stressed.

He contended that the DCFS ensures that children who are victims of such crimes are provided with the necessary services, including counseling to address the complex issues and reduce risk factors they may be exposed to prevent future risk of harm.

Mr Daley’s case reignited social and community activist Sandra Hill call for a sex offenders registry in Cayman.

Six years have passed since she delivered a 1,100 signature petition calling for the creation of the public sex offenders’ registry in Cayman. However she said nothing has changed since then and she summed up the inordinate delay in moving the matter forward as a clear indication that no importance is being placed on the creation of a public sex offenders’ registry in Cayman.

Minister Bodden said the Children Law (2012 Revision) addresses the well-being of children who may be at risk of significant harm.

The post Child abuse cases on the rise appeared first on The Cayman Reporter.

A woman was robbed of her purse by armed and masked assailants as she returned to her South Sound residence in the early hours of Monday 30 May.

Just before 2:00am on Monday, Royal Cayman Islands Police Service (RCIPS) officers responded to a report of a robbery at a residence on South Sound Road in the vicinity of Crewe Road.

The victim had arrived home a few minutes before and was followed into the entryway of the house by two masked men, each about 5’9” in height. One of the men was carrying what appeared to be a knife.  The culprits grabbed the victim’s handbag and then ran off on foot.  The victim was not harmed.

Anyone with information about this incident is encouraged to call George Town CID at 949-4222. Anonymous tips can be provided via the Miami-based call centre of Crime Stoppers at 800-8477(TIPS), or online at the link: https://www.tipsubmit.com/WebTips.aspx?AgencyID=681.

The post Woman robbed at knifepoint in South Sound home appeared first on The Cayman Reporter.

The Treasure Islands resort on Seven Mile Beach was listed for sale in 2015 for US$15,475,000. It was later purchased by Howard Hospitality Group (HHG) and will re-open as a Margaritaville Beach Resort following an extensive redesign and renovation project. Finance Minister Hon Marco Archer noted that, “The real estate sector recovered during the year as the total value of property transfers grew by 8.8 per cent to $612.2 million, aided by the transfer of properties along the Seven Mile Beach corridor.”

The Cayman Islands output growth in the year 2015, estimated at 2 per cent, declined in comparison to the previous year when it was recorded at 2.4 per cent.

Finance Minister Hon Marco Archer pointed this out in his 2016/2017 budget address on Monday, 30 May.

Despite the reduction in economic performance, last year Gross Domestic Product (GDP) was higher than the average of the previous four years of 1.6 per cent the minister noted.

The minister stated, “The services sector which accounted for 94.7 per cent of GDP in 2015, led the economic performance with a 1.9 percent growth rate, driven by greater economic activity in real estate, renting and business activities; other services; utilities; and financing and insurance services. The exception was hotels and restaurants which declined slightly due to a slowdown in the growth of stay-over arrivals primarily due to a lack of available room stock.”

There was an estimated increase of 2.9 per cent in the real estate, renting and business activities sector. Business services was the most dominant sector due to higher registration of companies and partnerships for the second consecutive year.

“The real estate sector recovered during the year as the total value of property transfers grew by 8.8 per cent to $612.2 million, aided by the transfer of properties along the Seven Mile Beach corridor,” Mr Archer noted.

Work permits for domestic workers increased thereby generating 3.4 per cent growth of services, which included households as employers.

Higher electricity and water consumption with the increase in population, and lower fuel cost, spurred a 2.1 per cent increase in the utilities sector.

The financing and insurance services sector, which accounted for approximately 41.0 per cent of GDP, expanded by 1.3 per cent in 2015 from 1.0 per cent in 2014.

“Insurance services grew as the increase in gross premiums outweighed net claims. Modest growth in financing services was due mainly to higher interest income in the local banking sector as domestic credit increased and the weighted average interest spread widened,” Mr Archer explained.

Due to indicators such as the volume of imported building materials Mr Archer reasoned that the construction sector expanded by 5.2 per cent. This may have been the result of several large on-going private and public sector projects, he said.

A 2.0 per cent growth in non-oil merchandise imports led to the wholesale and retail trade sector estimated growth of 1.1 per cent.

Growth in the transportation, storage and communication sector was estimated at 0.7 per cent.

“This sector benefitted from a higher number of cruise visitor arrivals coupled with the higher volume of cargo transportation. In the telecommunications sector, broadband connections grew by 16.7 per cent; however, total domestic and international paid calls, measured in minutes, continued on a downward trajectory as the use of VOIP becomes more popular,” Mr Archer declared.

Furthermore, government services expanded by 2.3 per cent, mainly as a result of a marginally higher staff count and a 4.0 per cent increase in salaries for core government employees in mid-2015.

“In 2015, the average consumer price index (CPI) declined by 2.3 percent compared to an average increase of 1.3 percent in 2014. The deflation occurred as downward pressure on prices for oil and oil-related goods and services and housing rentals outweighed upward pressure in housing rentals caused by an expansion in domestic demand from a higher population and increased economic activity,” Mr Archer said.

He continued, “The deflation in 2015 was directly related to the lower price indices for housing and utilities, transport, restaurants and hotels, and miscellaneous goods and services. The price index for housing and utilities fell by 6.9 percent. The cost of electricity, gas and other fuels, water supply and miscellaneous services also fell with the decline in oil prices. The latter also reduced the operation of the personal transport equipment component within the transport price index. The restaurants and hotels price index declined mainly due to slower growth in the numbers of stay-over visitors,” he went on.

“In 2015, the growth in GDP was accompanied by growth in the labour force by 3.6 percent to reach 39,138 persons,” said Mr Archer.

Furthermore, total employment increased by 4.0 per cent while the unemployment rate fell to 4.2 per cent, with both Caymanian and non-Caymanian unemployment rates falling to 6.2 per cent and 1.4 percent, respectively.

“In 2015, the balance of payments current account deficit was estimated to have narrowed by 23.1 percent due mainly to lower merchandise imports. Additionally, estimated visitors’ expenditure was higher because of strong growth in cruise visitors and marginal improvement in air arrivals. Financial services continued to provide significant inflows of revenue as new company registrations and new partnership registrations continued to increase. On the other hand, the outflow of workers’ remittances is estimated to have grown slightly as foreign employment increased,” said Mr Archer.

He also outlined the world economy noting that the International Monetary Fund reported, in its April 2016 World Economic Outlook, the global economic growth in 2015 was 3.1 per cent, down from 3.4 per cent in 2014.

“Global growth is forecasted to remain modest at 3.2 per cent in 2016, with stronger growth in 2017 at 3.5 per cent. The advanced economies are anticipated to expand by 1.9 per cent and 2.0 per cent in 2016 and 2017, respectively. Emerging markets and developing economies are projected to have a gradual recovery with average growth of 4.1 percent in 2016 and 4.6 per cent in 2017,” Mr Archer stated.

The post Archer: GDP higher than previous 4-year average in 2015 appeared first on The Cayman Reporter.

Newly-elected CIFA president Lee Ramoon with Brazilian football legend Romário.

The Cayman Islands Football Association (CIFA) held its annual CIFA Congress this past weekend whereby it elected a new President to replace out-going, beleaguered former President Bruce Blake who announced in March 2016 he would not be seeking re-election amidst controversy but would remain on the executive council as first vice president.

Taking on the top job for an organisation struggling to revitalise its image will be former national team captain Lee Ramoon who is considered “Cayman’s most successful footballer”, having played over 200 football games, including appearances on the national team, both as a player and eventual team captain.

Mr Ramoon beat out lone challenger Alfredo Whittaker for the president’s post in the Saturday internal election of the CIFA membership.

Speaking to the media following his election, Mr Ramoon acknowledged “everyone wants to see change and it is about to happen, but it will be baby steps”. Mr Ramoon said he was thankful to the membership for placing their trust in him to tackle the challenges ahead for the cash-strapped association while pledging to try and repair the association’s fractured relationship with the Cayman Islands government.

The Cayman Islands Football Association (CIFA) has been hindered by controversy since the arrest of former president Jeffrey Webb for racketeering in the international FIFA scandal and the revelations made during the recent local corruption trial of former treasurer, Canover Watson, which revealed a number of questionable financial transactions involving the local football association and other members of the current CIFA Executive Council..

Although no charges or further arrests have been made, and while those persons named during the trial have vehemently denied knowledge of any wrong doing, it has cast a long shadow of doubt over the entire administration and questions have been raised whether replacing merely the president is sufficient.

In March following then embattled Mr Blake’s announcement that he would not seek re-election and would instead stand down and welcome a duly elected successor at the CIFA Congress, former Director of National Teams, Renard Moxam called for a “clearing of the decks” and the instalment of new leaders at every level of the executive council, not only in the president role.

He maintained at the time that “in order to maintain the integrity of the Association,” he said, “It’s up to the players and coaches” attached to each club to “say enough is enough“ and demand changes. Changes he said “which are essential for the success of future generations”.

This was the similar stance taken by Sports Minister Hon Osbourne Bodden who in February 2016 issued a strong statement in the media that the government would not be funding any aspect of CIFA programmes until it had been satisfied that “certain financial irregularities” first brought to light by the Canover Watson corruption trial were addressed.

“After listening and hearing the stuff that came out of the Canover Watson trial, which is now done so we are free to talk about it, we heard about the accusation of money being funneled through CIFA,” the Minister stated while being interviewed on local television.

He added, “I think that without a doubt in the interest of football the CIFA executive who has been there and have been involved for a long time, should question themselves. How can you remain there under a cloud like that? For the interest of football they should do the right thing and the honourable thing” calling for all involved to step down.

Though Mr Moxam was unavailable for comment by press time, The Cayman Reporter did speak with former national team player and current coordinator of the national youth football programme, Neil Murray who said, “The elections were a long time in coming but it was understandable why it had taken so long. The process was handled professionally and without any contention” and called it a “fair and justifiable result”.

Although Mr Murray expressed disappointment that not all the clubs who were entitled to vote were present to cast their vote, he gave his support for Mr Ramoon who he said was “an excellent choice”.

Mr Murray added that Mr Ramoon’s “reputation on and off the field as well as his professional career accomplishments speak for themselves. He played the game at the highest level and his passion for the game is without question. It’s about time we actually has someone on the Executive who understands the importance of playing a game and representing your country on the field.”

When asked what he thought the most pressing priorities for the new president should be, Mr Murray stated that he believed “Lee’s focus will be on the youth and establishing proper youth programmes within the clubs and leagues.”

He added that “clubs must contribute to the development of our youth leagues and other clubs must be willing to assist those clubs who experience difficulties with starting their youth programmes.”

While stipulating that the seniors leagues should not go ignored, he acknowledged that “the greatest emphasis must now be placed on your youth and their future, above all else.”

Mr Ramoon was not available for comment at press time.

The post Lee Ramoon elected new CIFA President appeared first on The Cayman Reporter.

Her Excellency Governor Helen Kilpatrick said the initiatives outlined in her speech last year are either in progress or have been accomplished.

Her Excellency Governor Helen Kilpatrick delivered her Throne Speech on Monday, 30 May outlining the government’s plans for the 2016-2017 budget year.

She said the initiatives outlined in her speech last year are either in progress or have been accomplished.

“In addition, with this budget, the government will have met all the targets required by the Public Management and Finance Law and the Framework for Fiscal Responsibility and thus within the time span agreed with the United Kingdom government,” the governor announced.

She said this should be the final budget to require advance approval from the UK.

She stated that a substantial surplus has helped to improve business confidence and investment.

This surplus allows government to reduce import duties and fees, resulting in a fall in the average prices of goods, which thereby benefits individuals and businesses. One such good is diesel used to generate electricity. Due to the lowering of import duty on the diesel, and the fall in oil prices electricity costs have also decreased.

The surplus has also allowed the current administration to continue addressing the problem of civil service pay stagnation, she said.

Governor Kilpatrick stated because of increase in economic activity, employment – particularly of Caymanians – has improved significantly with the 2015 seeing the best employment figures since 2007.

She highlighted the “Ready 2 Work” programme and its aim to assist Caymanians finding it difficult to obtain or keep employment.

“This important initiative seeks to give individuals the dignity of work as well as to provide economic benefits for employees and employers,” the governor stated.

She noted that the Ministry of District Administration has plans for projects that will help to meet its goal of job creation in Cayman Brac and Little Cayman where economic sustainability is a concern.

“The government maintains a strong and clear determination to meet international standards across its wide range of operations. I refer not only to regulation of the Cayman Islands international financial services sector, but also to procurement standards, gender equality, and improvements to intellectual property and copyright laws,” she said.

She further stated, “All of these matter to Cayman’s economy and to providing for a fairer society for all. The introduction of a National Minimum Wage, just two months ago, along with pending amendments to the Labour Law, will contribute to this aim.

Governor Kilpatrick noted that the government showed its commitment to international standards at the recent anti-corruption summit in London. There, the officials stated that the Cayman Islands has upheld its pledge to transparency and should have a seat at the table when decisions are made. Ms Kilpatrick said the UK agreed.

“The relationship between the United Kingdom and Cayman Islands governments remains strong, and both are committed to working together for the good of the global community,” she declared.

Furthermore, Cayman Finance backed the government’s position at the summit demonstrating the high level of cooperation and partnership the Ministry of Financial Services and the financial services industry maintain.

The ministry is preparing for several important international assessments in the upcoming year, the governor shared.

“The ministry is also prioritising enhancements to mechanisms for the exchange of beneficial ownership information, ahead of the June 2017 deadline agreed with the UK. The government will also enact and amend legislation dealing with financial services and data protection,” she stated.

“The Ministry of Finance, meanwhile, is working to develop tools that will provide more up-to-date and detailed information about all areas of our economy. This kind of evidence based decision making will be a model for the public sector,” she said.

Another plan on the government’s agenda is for the public sector to provide a level of service that is on par with competing jurisdictions. This initiative is being headed by the Deputy Governor.

“The first item from the Project Future programme that Cabinet has approved, is the creation of an Office of the Ombudsman,” said the governor.

This will combine the functions of the Complaints and Information commissions, as well as the new Police Complaints Commission and should be implemented by the end of the year.

Governor Kilpatrick said, “In addition, the Public Authorities Bill will be introduced in the 2016-2017 fiscal year, and will aim to increase the effectiveness and efficiency of the public sector more widely.

“To facilitate a more modern approach to doing business, the Cabinet Office will coordinate public sector efforts to make improvements in cyber security and strategic communications during the next financial year. There will be continued focus on the use of technology to deliver and improve services,” she added.

Also on the government’s agenda is the continuation of major capital works that will enhance air and cruise tourism, modernise waste management, improve roads and revitalise the country’s capital.

“Work has begun on a new boardwalk and park in South Sound, and other new public parks are expected to be completed in the coming year,” said the governor. She mentioned that work to make a long term residential mental health facility for Caymanians will continue, but did not say when it is expected to be completed.

“The National Solid Waste Management Strategy has been finalised, and work is progressing on the Integrated Solid Waste Management System,” she continued. She added that the government will be announcing plans on recycling and the removal of old tyres at the landfill soon.

“The Ministry of Health will continue its efforts to eradicate the aedes aegypti mosquito, and thus help keep residents safe from harmful mosquito borne illness such as the Zika virus,” said the governor.

The Ministry of Education, Employment and Gender Affairs, has several plans in the works. They include labour and pensions legislative reform to clarify the law and increase compliance and the September launch of a second action plan focussed on improvement in schools. Improvements to school infrastructure will also continue.

Ms Kilpatrick asserted the government is working to boost the care given to those most in need through better social policy, programmes and services.

“In addition to introducing a national policy for older people, the Ministry of Community Affairs will streamline the processing of applications from those most in need. Caymanians, and residents of all ages, rightly place great importance on personal security. I will be asking the new Commissioner of Police to review the operations of the Royal Cayman Islands Police Service and to put forward recommendations for improvements,” she said.

She continued, “In addition, the Ministry of Home Affairs will develop interdisciplinary approaches to crime reduction and child protection between the agencies responsible for criminal justice, public safety and national security. Capacity-building, standard setting and, as elsewhere, the use of technology will be prioritised.

“The Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions will upgrade its electronic case management system, in order to collect performance data more reliably and improve the link between the Police and Courts. The Judicial Department will introduce mediation for family proceedings in both the Grand and Summary courts, to help parties reach settlements and avoid protracted legal proceedings,” she added.

Governor Kilpatrick further mentioned that the civil service will ensure that the electorate is educated about the new electoral system to be introduced, and that Election Day goes smoothly.

Ms Kilpatrick’s tenure as governor will end in September 2017. She said she looks forward to what the next year holds.

The post Governor delivers Throne Speech appeared first on The Cayman Reporter.

Amidst much self-congratulation by the current administration, the 2016-2017 18-month budget was delivered on Monday 30 May in the Legislative Assembly.

Through addresses by the Governor, the Premier and the Minister of Finance, we learned of the government’s spending plans through the May 2017 General Elections and beyond.

What caught our eye first was the “sweetening of the pot” awarded to civil servants as a one-off payment next month.

Could this perhaps be a gesture of appeasement following this administration’s stated intention of having public employees begin contributing to their own health insurance costs? That announcement caused significant grumbling among the ranks and also got some push back from the Civil Service Association.

Did someone in the political leadership remember that the Civil Service makes up the largest voting bloc in the country? It does seem like the payment could be a last minute reminder that this administration is looking out for the public employees and seeking their continued support.

“Given the continual improved performance of the budget over this past year, Government will this year pay a one-time gratuity of 2.2 per cent of annual salary to all civil servants. This will be paid with June salaries and amounts to about $3.7 million, which will be paid from the 2015-2016 surplus,” Premier McLaughlin said. He explained that the payment will not impact expenditure in the upcoming budget.

While we agree that hard working public servants should be rewarded, isn’t the four per cent cost of living increase they received last year enough, especially when combined with the $2.0 million set aside in the upcoming budget “for the implementation of a remuneration strategy to address pay stagnation and pay competitiveness for Civil Servants?”

We would argue that by and large, salaries and benefits for public employees already compare favourably with those offered in the private sector. Additionally, workers in the private sector do not receive cost of living increases at all. Normally, raises and bonuses are based solely on performance.

Additionally, public employees at the upper pay grades make salaries far and above the average private sector employee (unless you’re comparing them to the remuneration stratosphere of legal and accounting firm partners and the like.)

Shouldn’t any kind of reward be both based on performance and also pro-rated based on salary scale? For example – if you make CI$3,000 per month, shouldn’t you get a higher percentage than those who make CI$10,000 a month? And shouldn’t it also be based on performance as well? In this case it seems really unfair that an underperforming employee will get the same percentage as a stellar one who regularly meets and exceeds their targets.

It just seems to be a very ad hoc payment that does not meet clear criteria – and would seem to go against the fiscally conservative credentials of this administration.

But that is just one aspect of the budget that raised our eyebrows.

The other is the amount allocated to the improvement of public education. We have seen last year that the state of public education is not good, to put it mildly. The majority of our schools were given failing grades by external schools inspectors. We also saw just last week a petition by the Savannah Primary School PTA for an increase in basic resources for that school, which does not currently have what is required to meet the needs of its burgeoning population.

We do see that $4.2 million has been allocated for “enhancements to Public Education Services through the implementation of recommendations emanating from the recent independent review of the Cayman Islands Public Education System and also a series of baseline school inspection reports.”

And we are happy for it. But is this sufficient? Are we really spending enough on improving our education system – which is really the foundation upon which our country’s future will be built?

We cannot help but feel that it is another sop, or appeasement, to smooth the ruffled feathers of anxious parents and fed-up educators.

Especially when we see that more than three times this amount (CI$12.7 million) is being devoted to the Cayman Turtle Farm “to fund debt servicing and operational losses.”

Huh? What? So propping up a failing facility is worth three times the expenditure being devoted to improve our country’s education system?

Again, we must question the spending priorities of our government. If we are as flush with cash as we are told, then why not spend the money where it is most needed and where it will do the most good?

And sadly, what we see as a focus on the wrong end of reducing crime in terms of both dollars and sense is also highlighted in the new budget.

With the Conditional Release law now in effect, $0.5 million will be released for the implementation of a Conditional Release Programme “to better enable prisoners to successfully reintegrate into society as productive citizens following release from incarceration.”

We appreciate that this is necessary, as recidivism in Cayman is uncommonly high. But, what is being spent to prevent at-risk youth from turning to a life of crime in the first place? That’s the figure that we would like to see.

What, we ask, are our priorities?

The post Where are our priorities? appeared first on The Cayman Reporter.

Donnette Thompson with her mother Noreen.

Social activist and father of a special needs child Kent McTaggart has taken up the mantle demanding help for Donnette Thompson, a 10-year old girl who was born with cerebral palsy following a medical injury she sustained at birth.

She also became the subject of a case that led to the recent amendment of the Health Services Authority Law reversing a 12-year old clause exempting doctors from lawsuits in cases of medical malpractice or negligence.

Kent McTaggart

In February 2016, Justice Richard Williams upheld the controversial section 12 of the Health Services Authority Law that provided blanket immunity from medical malpractice suits, for anyone who works for the authority. In his ruling Justice Williams expressed being “personally uncomfortable” with the ruling he was obligated to uphold and said “the issue as to whether a statute providing immunity against claims in damages, including for clinical negligence, is incompatible with the Bill of Rights is one of great public importance.”

The law was repealed in May 2016 by unanimous vote in the Legislative Assembly, however according to Premier Hon Alden McLaughlin, the amendment would not apply retroactively, meaning there is no right to seek compensation in relation to anyone killed or injured as a result of medical negligence in the last 12 years; including the claims for damages made by Noreen Thompson, mother of Donnette Thompson.

A screen shot of the Go Fund Me page set up to help Donnette and her family.

Speaking on “Straight Talk with Austin Harris” on Monday, Kent McTaggart challenged members of both the public and private sector to step up and “change the stars” for this young Caymanian child “by doing the right thing” and contributing money to the family of Donnette Thompson.

McTaggart said, “Not only did our Government fail one of our own, but they continue to ignore the pleas for help, while seemingly being satisfied that their repeal of the law was sufficient.”

Mr McTaggart however did not agree, as he challenged the islands’ legislators to part with a portion of their hefty monthly pay-cheques, which in some cases are over $20,000 per month for some legislators who double dip by collecting both a salary and pension.

He is being sssisted by other likeminded individuals in the Cayman community, such as Justin Frazer who has created a fundraising and public awareness online platform located at www.gofundme.com/RescueDonnette.

The webpage allows members of the local and international community to make financial donations that will be used in the daily care of Donnette, something Mr McTaggart says is badly needed.

Aiding fundraising efforts is also Shyvon Hydes, who is providing logistical support for an effort that has set a goal to raise CI$125,000.

“The Government provides a monthly stipend of CI$550 for Donnette,” Mr McTaggart said. “But this paltry sum pales in comparison to the real costs associated with the care required for a special needs child like Donnette.”

Donnette was diagnosed at birth with Hypoxic Ischaemic Encephalopathy (HIE) and subsequently thereafter developed Spastic Quadriparesis, as well as a Bilateral Brachial Plexus Palsy. As a result of the severe disabilities it is unlikely that Donnette will ever live an independent life.

Mr McTaggart said, “What has happened to Donnette and her family is nothing short of a complete disgrace! This precious little girl Donnette has severe physical and mental handicaps caused from medical malpractice. The laws of the Cayman Islands protected the medical practitioners from liability, therefore Donnette’s family has been essentially forced into poverty while trying to care for her.”

In order to meet her essential needs, Mr Mctaggart appealed to members of the public to “search deep within and then dig into your pockets and to help us raise a little money to assist sweet Donnette in getting the necessary care she requires and to further alleviate the heavy burden her mother is under.”

Donations are being accepted either directly online at GoFundMe, which as of press time had already generated just over CI$3,700, or by contacting Kent McTaggart on 525-2992, or Shyvon Hydes on 929-1979.

The post Child at centre of HSA Law controversy not helped by amendments appeared first on The Cayman Reporter.

One-off 2.2 per cent gratuity payment next month

Officers of the Royal Cayman Islands Police (RCIPS) stand in formation as they formed the honour guard outside the Legislative Assembly on Monday (30 May) ahead of the ceremonial start of the 2016/2017 session. Photo: Reshma Ragoonath

June salary for public servants just got a little sweeter as Government announced the payment of a one-time gratuity of 2.2 per cent of annual salary for all civil servants giving them some extra spending money ahead of the summer vacation.

Premier Hon Alden McLaughlin made the announcement on Monday (30 June) as he delivered the last policy statement from his Progressives-led administration before the 2017 general elections entitled “Delivering on our promises.”

Mr McLaughlin lauded Finance and Economic Development Minister Hon Marco Archer and his team for the “prudent” fiscal management of the public purse which saw multi-million dollar surpluses continued for the third straight year.

“Over our last three budgets we have generated net surpluses totalling almost $400 million dollars. We did this despite giving up about $30 million dollars annually in tax reductions and correcting inequalities in civil servants’ salaries. Effectively, this represents a $30 million dollar annual economic stimulus,” he said.

As a reward the Premier announced the one-off payment which he said was “to recognise the valuable contributions that civil servants have made over the past year.”

“Given the continual improved performance of the budget over this past year, Government will this year pay a one-time gratuity of 2.2 per cent of annual salary to all civil servants. This will be paid with June salaries and amounts to about $3.7 million, which will be paid from the 2015-2016 surplus,” Premier McLaughlin said as he spoke following the ceremonial opening of the Legislative Assembly.

He explained that the payment will not impact expenditure in the upcoming budget.

Those surpluses, he said, have also been used to bolster cash reserves.

He pointed out that for 2015-2016 there is sufficient cash in reserves to fund more than the required 90 days under the Public Management and Finance Law.

“And because we have had good surpluses, during last year’s budget we were able to announce an across-the-board cost of living increase of 4 per cent for civil servants that became effective July 1st, 2015,” he added.

The cost of that, he said, was about $7.5 million dollars per annum “but represents money that is spent here at home and put right back into this economy.”

This, he said, was in addition to a 2.5 per cent gratuity payment provided to civil servants in June 2014 in recognition of the hard work done to help improve Government efficiencies.

The Premier, in outlining government’s performance, said as announced during the Strategic Policy Statement delivered in November, Government will also start to address pay stagnation for some of the longest serving employees by making provision in the upcoming budget.

“Some of these hardworking and dedicated staff have had their salaries frozen for as long as seven years and yet they see new entrants to the service being able to negotiate higher salaries when they are employed. We will begin the work to correct this in the 2016-2017 budget,” he said.

Government, he said, is using surpluses to repay Government debt.

“Over the past three years surpluses have given us the ability to pay down debt by $71 million dollars. As the Minister of Finance will no doubt mention, the current budget will have sufficient surpluses to reduce the debt burden even further. And we have set aside $17 million dollars in a debt service sinking fund, which can be used to repay debt in future years as needed,” he added.

He also pointed out that paying down debt reduces the burden of financing costs to government and also frees up funds for other uses, such as improving education, funding the cost of a proper waste management system, or providing needed infrastructure.

Given that it was his last policy statement before the next polls Mr McLaughlin seized the opportunity to take a jab at his party’s main political rival the Cayman Democratic Party (CDP) formerly called the United Democratic Party (UPD).

This as he pointed out that “by comparison, the UDP’s last three budgets created net surpluses totalling only $41 million dollars.”

The Premier said that Cayman’s economy is continuing to expand with economic growth of about 2 per cent annually since 2013 – far exceeding the 0.81 per cent economic growth experienced during the first three years of the UDP’s administration.

“So yes, since we took office there has been a tremendous economic boost. Today we have an economy buoyed by increased investor confidence where private sector investment is growing and is set to grow further with major initiatives that are under way or in the planning stages,” he said.

The Premier also pointed out that surpluses also allowed Government to lower taxes over the past two budgets, thus reducing the cost of living.

“The duty paid by licensed traders was reduced from 22 per cent to 20 per cent during the last budget. This cost Government $4 million dollars per annum in lost revenues but also reduced the import duty costs to businesses and allowed them the ability to provide better pricing to local customers, helping to reduce the cost of living to households and businesses,” he added.

The post Public Servants get June sweetener appeared first on The Cayman Reporter.

Government intends, as a matter of urgency, to legalise of the use of medical cannabinoid oil for the treatment of cancer and glaucoma among other conditions. This was announced by Premier Hon Alden McLaughlin on Monday 30 May as he delivered the Progressives-led Government policy statement following the formal opening of the Legislative Assembly. Photo: medicalmarijuana.co.uk

In a surprising announcement Premier Hon Alden McLaughlin says government intends, as a matter of urgency, to legalise of the use of medical cannabinoid oil for the treatment of cancer and glaucoma among other conditions.

However having said that the Premier, who made the announcement while delivering the Progressives-led Policy Statement entitled-“Delivering on our promises” on Monday (30 May), made it clear government is not legalising the use of medical marijuana in Cayman Islands.

“I am not talking about legalising the use of the cannabis plant itself for medical or other uses,” he clarified as he spoke following the ceremonial opening of the Legislative Assembly on Monday.

While debate for the legalisation of marijuana continues to rage on globally, some countries have opted to allow the use of the narcotic in controlled doses for medicinal purposes.

Just this month, according to the UK Telegraph, Germany announced that it will legalise cannabis for medicinal purposes early next year. A draft bill is in the process of being finalised. The issue has been been on the Caricom agenda for quite some time. Last year Jamaica decriminalised small portions of marijuana paving the way for the legalisation of the drug for medical purposes.

Last year Bodden Town MLA Alva Suckoo began a public campaign to solicit views on whether he should bring a motion on the legalisation of medical marijuana in Cayman. He received mixed support on the issue.

On Monday Premier McLaughlin, speaking on the issue, said under the proposed chances doctors will be able to prescribe the use of the oil, which derived from the cannabis or marijuana plant, to patients in need.

“I am speaking here about an oil extract from the cannabis plant that has been prepared for medical purposes and that will be imported into the Cayman Islands in a fashion similar to medical morphine,” he explained.

Premier McLaughlin, speaking in the LA on the decision, said, “After carefully considering the merits and demerits of legalising the use of medical cannabinoid oil to treat those in our community with a debilitating disease, whether cancer, glaucoma, or perhaps even severe epilepsy, Government is persuaded that it is better to favour hope and compassion over fear.”

He said Cabinet has issued instructions to the Legal Department to draft a Bill that will allow medical doctors to prescribe cannabinoid oil to patients who may benefit.

“We are treating this as a matter of urgency for we are keenly aware that time is not a luxury for many of those whom this drug may benefit,” he said.

The Premier, in an attempt to counter detractors to the proposed change, pointed to an ailing Caymanian woman whose option at this point is “death or death.”

“For those who may doubt the wisdom of this decision, I wish they could have been present when a young Caymanian, who in making a case for his very sick wife to be able to access the oil that they believe will help defeat her illness, said that his wife’s choice currently is ‘death or death’. That is their reality for there is no standard medication or treatment available that gives them hope,” he said.

The Premier, speaking on health in his policy statement presentation, also stressed that Cayman is “badly in need of a proper mental health facility.”

He said cabinet has approved Outline Business Case on the facility and the 2016-2017 budget contains funding to start “this work in earnest so that we can provide a modern, humane environment for the treatment of mental illness in our community.”

“We are spending tens of thousands of dollars to send people overseas for treatment and the number of people in need continues to rise. Here at home some of our residents with mental illness are homeless, some go in and out of our inpatient unit, some live with family and friends while others are in prison. With that in mind, this Government has determined that we need to find a way to correct this,” he added.

The Premier also pointed out that a modern Disabilities Law has also been long overdue and assured that in “the coming year this will be corrected.”

He also explained that during this next year the Department of Health Regulatory Services will review the registration process with the aim of introducing an electronic system to file applications for healthcare practitioners.

“They will also work with the Health Insurance Commission to investigate the feasibility of a national health insurance plan for retirees and senior citizens,” Premier McLaughlin added.

The Ministry of Community Affairs, Youth and Sports, he said, is continuing its work to develop a National Policy of Older Persons and is completing the Poor Persons Relief Regulations to streamline the processing of the applications of those most in need.

“The Ministry will continue to advocate for and strengthen child safeguarding measures and therapeutic rehabilitation for the protection of all children in the Cayman Islands. Counselling and family services will be expanded and enhanced to more effectively address a broader range of emerging needs in our society with a goal to improve the lives of those who access those services,” Mr McLaughlin added.

The Ministry, he said, has also developed preliminary recommendations for the improvement of physical education and school sports.

“We believe physical education and school sports are important to our community as a whole to increase physical competence, health-related fitness, self-responsibility and just plain old enjoyment of physical activity,” the Premier, who is also the Health Minister, added.

The post Gov’t to approve use of medical cannabis oil appeared first on The Cayman Reporter.

3.7 per cent increase over 2015/2016 budget

Finance and Economic development Minister Hon Marco Archer kept the Progressives-led administration’s promise of no new taxes or fees in the 2016-2017 national budget as he revealed the $826.4 million fiscal package.

With the clock ticking closer to the 2017 general elections Finance Minister Hon Marco Archer raised the stakes on Monday (30 May) as he revealed the $826.4m budget announcing spending in keys areas including social programmes, education and scholarships.

He also announced Government’s intention to $103.3m in capital investments which would include $7.9million for the continuation of the John Gray High School as well as $6.5 million for “improved solid waste handling facility.”

Mr Archer, delivering his 2016/2017 budget presentation entitled, “Securing Cayman’s future,” following the ceremonial opening of the Legislative Assembly, said the budget forecasts total operating and financing expenses of $862.4 million for core government which “represents a 3.7 per cent annualised increase over the 2015/16 Budget.”

However he assured that during 2016/17 “there will be no new borrowings and the Entire Public Sector (EPS) Debt balance will decline by $70.3 million to $523.1 million resulting in a Debt-to-GDP ratio of 17.8 per cent for the EPS. This is a significant improvement over the 27.2 per cent that existed in 2012/13.”

Debate on the national budget is set to begin at 10 am in the LA tomorrow (Wednesday 1 June).

Operating revenues, the minister pointed out, are forecast to be $908.5 million, adding that “in line with our commitment to keep the tax burden low, there will be no new revenue measures introduced in 2016/17.”

He assured that government’s net operating position should be positive meaning that core Government revenues should be greater than its expenses.

“For 2016/17 compliance is achieved as the Government forecasted revenue of $908.5 million is $46.1 million greater than its forecast operating expenses of $862.4 million. Net worth should be positive as Core Government’s assets less its liabilities should be positive: at the end of the 2016/17, the Government’s assets are forecasted to exceed its liabilities by approximately $1.2 billion,” the minister added.

Mr Archer said government’s prudence and sound financial management has put Cayman on a stable economic footing and all one has to do is look to neighbouring countries to see what happens in the absence of such management.

“There really is an important and productive purpose for this money. If it is squandered and not used productively, this and future generations will bear the burden for a very long time. If we are not careful, the country may become like Venezuela today where squandering of the country’s wealth and resources has created an economic disaster and third world living conditions,” the minister contended.

Minister Archer, in delving into the increased expenditure, explained that “$4.2 million has been allocated for enhancements to Public Education Services through the implementation of recommendations emanating from the recent independent review of the Cayman Islands Public Education System and also a series of baseline school inspection reports.”

While some $3.2 million, he said, will be used for improvements to the regulatory services provided by the Cayman Islands Monetary Authority (CIMA) for the financial services industry “in order to keep pace with ever-evolving international regulatory requirements and to prepare for the upcoming International Monetary Fund (IMF) and Financial Action Task Force (FATF) assessments in 2017.”

Minister Archer stated that improved public health programmes and management and control of communicable diseases have been allocated $2.1 million, while $2.0 million has been set aside for the implementation of a remuneration strategy to address pay stagnation and pay competitiveness for Civil Servants.

A $1.4 million allocation has been listed for the May 2017 General Election which is just under year away and will see the implementation of the One Man One Vote system and 19 Single Member Constituencies (SMCS).

With the growing number of applicants seeking assistance Government, Minister Archers said, has allocated $1.1 million for additional resources for the Needs Assessment Unit and the Department of Children and Family Services “to enhance services to the most vulnerable and at risk persons in our society.”

The Judiciary and Legal Aid will receive $1.0 million for increased support services and $0.4 million has been allocated for the implementation of various public sector reforms under the umbrella of Project Future.

With the Conditional Release law now in effect the Finance Minister announced $0.5 million will be released for the implementation of a Conditional Release Programme “to better enable prisoners to successfully reintegrate into society as productive citizens following release from incarceration.”

He also shared that $0.3 million has been set aside for the creation the contentious Office of Public Ombudsman.

The Minister, while mapping out expenditure for the new 18-month budget cycle, said, in 2016/17 the Government will continue to focus on cash and debt management, while also proactively managing our long-term liabilities.

“It is critical that we continue with this strategy, not just from the perspective of Framework for Fiscal Responsibility (FFR) compliance, but because it is prudent and wise. We need to make certain that we build a firm foundation for truly sustainable long term financial stability, enabling the country to provide high quality public services to future generations of Caymanians,” he contended.

He said for 2016/17 Government intends to make capital investments totaling $103.3 million without any new long-term borrowings.

“The planned Capital Investments will be entirely funded from existing resources – that is – cash generated from operating activities and surplus cash reserves.   $68.1 million will be invested in Core Government assets,” he explained.

The major investments also includes; $6.9 million for the revitalisation of central George Town project; $6.5 million for improved solid waste handling facility and $6.0 million for the purchase of lands for national environmental conservation purposes – this item will be funded by a withdrawal from the Environmental Protection Fund,” he said.

Minister Archer also indicated that $1.0 million will be spent for enhanced cyber security for the Government’s information technology infrastructure, while $3.4 million will be spent for upgrades to the road network.

A further $2.5 million will be spent for a residential mental health treatment facility; $1.5 million for a Household Recycling Centre; and $0.5 million for the ongoing development of the cruise berthing project.

Mr Archer, in his budget presentation, said the Cayman Islands is in “an enviable financial position. We are now experiencing; continuous economic growth; operating surpluses by controlling expenditure; rising cash reserves; declining Debt balances; declining Debt-to-GDP ratio; declining expenditure-to-GDP ratio; declining Revenue-to-GDP ratio (Tax Burden).

“The 2016/17 Budget continues these efforts and calls for no new borrowings and no new tax measures while delivering enhanced public services and advancing the development of key infrastructure projects,” the minister declared.

A total of $35.2 million will be invested in Statutory Authorities and Government Companies (SAGCs) to fund debt service obligations; operational losses and various capital projects, the minister said.

“The major investments in this category are; $12.7 million to the Cayman Turtle Farm (1983) Limited to fund debt servicing and operational losses; $7.7 million to Cayman Airways Limited to fund debt servicing obligations; $7.5 million to the Cayman Islands Airports Authority to fund the redevelopment and expansion of the passenger terminal at the Owen Roberts International Airport,” he said.

Added to this, the Minister also said, $3.4 million will be allocated to the National Housing Development Trust to fund debt servicing obligations, as well as, $2.0 million to the Cayman Islands Development Bank to fund debt servicing obligations and $1.6 million to the Health Services Authority to fund the purchase of various medical equipment and upgrades to facilities.

The 2016/17 Budget, he added, includes approximately $388.3 million of pension liability based on an actuarial accounting valuation report as at 30th June 2015 and estimated pension expenditure of $49.2 million.

“The forecast also includes an additional cash contribution to the Public Service Pensions Fund of $15.0 million in 2016/17, which directly reduces the pension liability. An accounting valuation is required by International Public Sector Accounting Standards (IPSAS) 25, Employee Benefit.”

The post Archer delivers $826.4 million fiscal package appeared first on The Cayman Reporter.

21-year-old Jaesha Hendrix was denied bail on Monday (30 May) when she appeared in court on drugs and perverting the course of justice charges. Ms Hendrix was initially listed as a missing person following her disappearance last October, but the RCIPS later revised that deeming her a wanted person sought in connection with the supply of drugs.

Registered nursing assistant 21-year-old Jaesha Hendrix remains in custody after having been denied bail on Monday (30 May) when she appeared in court on drug related charges.

Ms Hendrix, who disappeared on 23 October, appeared in court on charges of conspiracy to supply drugs and conspiracy to obstruct, pervert and defeat justice. She was represented by attorney Prathna Bodden.

She was remanded into custody until 15 June.

Last Thursday (26 May) Ms Hendrix, after being on run for the last seven months, was arrested by officers in Bodden Town.

According to an RCIPS statement, issued Thursday (26 May), Ms Hendrix was “a wanted person whom the police have been seeking for over six months.”

“She has been arrested on suspicion of Being Concerned in the Supply of Drugs, and is currently in custody,” the police statement said.

Since Ms Hendrix’s disappearance from her Lakeside apartment, her mother Edith Scott, of Florida and who is originally from Cayman Brac, launched a public campaign searching for her daughter after a disturbing conversation with her in October.

Ms Scott said she was overjoyed her daughter is safe and that she was able to see her.

The post No bail for Jaesha appeared first on The Cayman Reporter.

The existing port on the George Town waterfront.

The Ministry of Tourism is choosing to keep out of the ongoing port debate between the Save Cayman group, which is against the current port proposal, and pro-port group Cayman’s Port Cayman’s Future.

When asked if the ministry would like to respond to points Save Cayman founder Keith Sahm made in previous articles published in The Cayman Reporter, the ministry’s Public Relations Manager Gina Matthews declined.

She replied, the ministry “prefers not to comment at this time”.

Minister of Tourism Hon Moses Kirkconnell

In its latest update on the port, given on 26 April, the ministry indicated that it is forging ahead with the port and has no intention of rescinding its decision.

At this time it had signaled the official opening of the tendering process for the controversial multi-million dollar cruise berthing facility. It announced advertisements for civil engineering design works for the facility are expected to appear in local and international media beginning on the day of the release.

The full tender process was scheduled to begin in May after successful tenders pre-qualified.

Deputy Premier and Minister for Tourism Hon Moses Kirkconnell said, “This next step of civil engineering design works represents significant progress and is needed for the financing model of the cruise lines.”

Since this announcement, Mr Sahm has continued to contest the move by warning Cayman not to make the same mistake as Miami, Florida, which is facing the repercussions of dredging in their port. Their port’s coral reefs have been badly damaged.

Additionally, Mr Sahm believes that some international environmental treaty such as the Convention on Biodiversity or organisation such as United Nations Environment Programme will foil the government’s plans to build the port.

He also argued that a public consultation conducted last year indicated that majority of the public was against the port, and therefore it is not “the mandate of the people” as the tourism minister previously stated.

While the ministry refused to comment, pro-port group founder Chris Kirkconnell jumped at the chance to counter Mr Sahm’s claims.

Mr Kirkconnell argued that the Miami Port project cannot be compared to Cayman’s port project because it is “on a completely different scale, scope and size”. He added that the technology used in the dredging of the Miami harbour and the duration of the dredging differ from what is being proposed for Cayman’s harbour. Furthermore, he said marine experts have advised him the geology and marine environment of Miami harbour is different from Cayman’s harbour.

He also argued, “Mr Sahm’s comments about public opinion on the cruise port fail to recognise that over one third of respondents were not Caymanian residents much less voters and many were also solicited from DEMA (The Diving Equipment & Marketing Association) and other international dive groups.”

The post Tourism ministry opts out of port debate appeared first on The Cayman Reporter.

Brothers Osbourne Douglas (front) and Justin Ramoon (back) on a visit to the crime scene during their murder trial for the killing of Jason Powery. Both men were found guilty of the murder, acting in a joint enterprise

Brothers Osbourne Douglas and Justin Ramoon were both found guilty of murder on Thursday 26 May in the killing of Jason Powery, acting in a joint enterprise.

Justice Charles Quin, following a judge alone trial, issued his ruling on Thursday afternoon.

Justin Ramoon, age 24, was named as the person who shot Mr Powery in the face at close range after he was handed the murder weapon by his brother, Mr Douglas – age 28. Mr Douglas then drove Mr Ramoon away from the scene of the crime.

All of this was according to the eyewitness testimony of two people present at the time of the murder.

Despite the defence attempting to discredit their testimony, Justice Quin found the accounts of the witnesses to be credible.

The 20-year-old victim Jason Powery was shot in the face at close range. No motive was supplied by the prosecution for the murder.

The 20-year-old victim was shot with a 9mm pistol.

The murder took place near the Globe Bar in central George Town on 1 July 2015.

Both men were also charged with and convicted of possession of an unlicenced firearm. However, the weapon was never recovered.

Despite a lack of forensic evidence, and no motive supplied by the prosecution for the crime, Justice Quin declared the brothers guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.

The two eye witnesses, both friends of the victim, testified that they saw Mr Douglas pass the gun to his brother and then witnessed Mr Ramoon shoot their friend in the face.

While no motive was supplied in court, police said during the investigation that they believed the crime to be gang related. The brothers convicted of the crime are from George Town and live near the scene of the murder. The victim was from West Bay.

In a lengthy verdict that took three hours to deliver, Justice Quin stated clearly that the Crown had proven its case beyond a reasonable doubt and that he found the eyewitness accounts to be truthful.

The brothers did not testify in their own defence. However, they denied committing the crime in police statements while admitting they had been in the area that night.

Their defence also categorised the eyewitnesses as gang members themselves, who were unreliable with reason to lie and cast blame on the defendants to protect themselves from prosecution.

Justice Quin rejected this contention and said he found both witnesses to be reliable, and that their testimony was backed up by CCTV evidence, as well as shell casings.

During the reading of the verdict, neither brother displayed any visible reaction.

Both brothers are no strangers to the criminal justice system, having both been charged and convicted of violent and gun crimes in the past.

Mr Douglas was previously convicted in 2011 of the murder of Omar Samuels in 2009. This verdict was later overturned on appeal. Mr Samuels was shot in the leg and bled to death in the Rock Hole area of George Town. Mr Douglas was also acquitted of a gun charge in 2012 due to lack of evidence.

Mr Ramoon was convicted in 2013 for wounding with intent for a 2012 stabbing and sentenced to seven years. This verdict was overturned on appeal in 2014. In 2010 he was convicted of possession of an imitation firearm and was sentenced to three years.

Following their conviction for Mr Powery’s murder, both men were remanded in custody until 14 July, when they will be sentenced.

While a life sentence is still mandatory for murder, the Conditional Release Law mandates tariffs be set for those convicted. Prior to its implementation in February of this year, life sentences in the Cayman Islands were whole life sentences under which convicted murderers either died in prison or were released at the discretion of the Governor.

The new law brings the Cayman Islands in line with UK law and abolishes the sentence of life without parole.

The sentencing guidelines in the law set the minimum tariff at 30 years for murder, but judges must also consider both aggravating and mitigating factors which may either lengthen or reduce that time.

The post Brothers guilty of murder appeared first on The Cayman Reporter.

Debate on the 2016/2017 budget is set to begin this morning in the Legislative Assembly. On Monday (30 May) Finance and Economic Minister Hon Marco Archer presented government’s $862.4 million fiscal package, a 3.7 per cent increase in spending over the 2015/2016 budget.

With pressure on to complete the budgetary process before the 30 June deadline legislators will be in for some late nights starting today as debate on Government’s $862.4 million fiscal package kicks off in the Legislative Assembly this morning.

On Monday (30 May) Premier Hon Alden McLaughlin sought the cooperation of the Opposition and Independents to defer Private Members’ Motions, which are usually set for Thursdays, in order to complete the debate and finance committee approval.

His request followed Finance and Economic Development Minister Hon Marco Archer’s delivery of the 2016/2017 budget and East End MLA Arden McLean’s query on government intends to proceed with the LA session.

The Independent MLA, prior to the adjournment of the House, questioned, “What is the Government intent in going forward over the next three weeks because we received notification that we are going to work until 7 at night. It is also the Government’s intent to work on Tuesdays as well, instead of four days? or over the weekends? Whichever the case may be.”

Premier McLaughlin, in response, explained that because of the length of time it takes to get through the debate speeches, as well as, the scrutiny by Finance Committee that he asked the clerk to indicate to members that the House would begin by working late.

“I believe that if we work until 7 from the outset we may avert the need to work into the wee hours of the morning as has been the case in the past. Depending on the progress that we make we may have to resort to more extreme measures, but I hope not,” Premier McLaughlin contended.

Tuesdays, he said, are Cabinet day so that will remain unchanged. However, the Premier reminded legislators that there are 19 members to speak as the official members all speak during the budget debate. He also asked for the

Working to 7pm, he said, should allow the debate to be completed by the end of this week or early next week. Deferring private motions until the completion of finance committee, he added, that would give members an additional day of Thursday to get through budget business and finance committee.

On Monday Minister Archer revealed government’s $862.4m budget announcing spending in keys areas and its intention to spend $103.3m in capital investments including a $7.9million for the continuation of the John Gray High School as well as $6.5 million for “improved solid waste handling facility.”

The allocation to the school construction, according to Premier McLaughlin, will see the completion of the gymnasium.

Mr Archer, in delivering his 2016/2017 budget presentation entitled, “Securing Cayman’s future,” said the budget forecasts total operating and financing expenses of $862.4 million for core government which “represents a 3.7 per cent annualised increase over the 2015/16 Budget.”

However, he assured that during 2016/17 there will be no new borrowings and the Entire Public Sector (EPS) Debt balance will decline by $70.3 million to $523.1 million resulting in a Debt-to-GDP ratio of 17.8 per cent for the EPS.

This, he said, is a significant improvement over the 27.2 per cent that existed in 2012/13.

In terms of economic stimulus measures, Mr Archer said, government will continue its reduction on import duty on diesel fuel used by CUC to generate electricity. As of 1 January reduced import duty from 50 cents to 25 cents, down from an initial price of 75 cents.

He also indicated that effective 1 July 2014 Government reduced import duty rates on items regularly charged at 22 per cent down to a 20 per cent rate for licensed traders only and that reduction will remain.

“The Government will also continue to offer the import duty concession on building materials which are currently being charged import duty at the rate of 15 per cent versus the normal range of 17 per cent to 22 per cent. This will continue to act as an incentive for the construction sector,” Minister Archer added.

Trade and Business Licence fees discounts for small and micro business, he added, will continue based on location; George Town and West Bay – 50 per cent discount; Bodden Town, North Side, East End, Cayman Brac and Little Cayman – 75 per cent discount.

“Government is currently developing a Concessions and Incentives policy framework and expects to complete this by 30 September 2016. It is intended that this policy will transition the country more toward deferring revenue to be paid at a future date rather than completely waiving the revenue to be paid,” Mr Archer added.

For the sister isles, the minister said, economic incentives will continue with a 100 per cent import duty waiver on building materials imported to Cayman Brac and Little Cayman; a 100 per cent import duty waiver on diesel fuel for Cayman Brac Power and Light; a 12.5 cents per gallon import duty rate (or an 83.3 per cent duty rate waiver) on the importation of motor gasoline to Cayman Brac; and a 100 per cent waiver on stamp duty for the purchase of land in Cayman Brac.

Minister Archer also indicated that transfer payments are budgeted to be $48.9 million with major items in this category being $15.9 million for Local and Overseas Scholarships; $11.7 million for Poor Relief Payments and Vouchers; $9.0 million for Ex-Gratia payments to Seamen and Veterans; and $2.3 million for Employment Initiatives.

Financing expenses are budgeted to be $38.9 million and covers the interest payments associated with the portfolio of Core Government Debt which is scheduled to decline during 2016/17 by $52.3 million, from $503.4 million to $451.1 million, he added.

The Core Government, he said, is forecasted to have bank account balances totalling $414.4 million for this fiscal year ending 30th June 2016, which is some $72.8 million more than the $341.6 million shown in the 2015/16 Budget.

The minister pointed out that for the first time since the 2004/5 fiscal year funds will be transferred to the General Reserves. He said $50 million will be transferred to the General Reserve Fund by 1 July 2016 taking the Fund up to $95.9 million.

The forecast closing cash position consists of an anticipated $281.6 million in the operating bank account and $132.8 million in restricted and reserve accounts, he further stated on Monday.

Minister Archer said Government taken the decision to transfer $18 million to the Public Service Pensions Fund by 30 June 2016, to reduce the liability associated with the provision of pension benefits to retired civil servants and parliamentarians.

The post Budget debate begins today appeared first on The Cayman Reporter.

HE Governor Helen Kilpatrick

Responding to the complaint filed by West Bay MLA Bernie Bush alleging inadequate performance over time but also misconduct on the part of out-going Commissioner of Police David Baines, pursuant to Section 44 of the Public Service Management Law, HE Governor Helen Kilpatrick sought first to draw the distinction between command decisions versus the execution of those decisions by subordinate officers on the ground.

In her response to Mr Bush, Governor Kilpatrick said “In considering whether any of the allegations made justify further investigation and/or disciplinary action, it is important to distinguish between complaints regarding the strategic and central control of an entire force by a chief officer versus complaints regarding the tactical execution of plans or tactical control of detachments on the ground by suburbanite officers.”

West Bay MLA Bernie Bush

In so doing, while providing a detailed response to the 20 questions, following legal advice, the Governor, in her estimation found that the complaints were largely “unsubstantiated” or “soley concerned with the conduct of subordinate officers for which the Commissioner should not be disciplinarily responsible.”

Dismissing the allegations, the governor provided a detailed response to the questions raised, citing repeatedly that “responsibility rests with either the Ministry of Home Affairs” or “subordinate officers” and were largely “out of the Commissioners control.” These factors whether it be the matter of missing drugs or firearms, the proper functioning of the CCTV systems, the high number of police vehicle crashes, missing video evidence or the theft of police vehicles, the governor said

In the matter if the 42 statute barred cases that failed to be prosecuted, Governor Kilpatrick stated, “The complaint largely concerns discrete actions by subordinate officers for which the Commissioner should not be held disciplinarily responsible.”

Outgoing Police Commissioner David Baines

In the matter of what Mr Bush defined in his original complaint as the “Search Warrant debacle” that alleged the RCIPS failed to properly caution a witness before an interview, leading to the Grand Court ruling that the statement was inadmissible, the governor insisted that “since the time of the interview the extent of citizens’ entitlement to free legal advice”, as outlined in the Bill of Rights, “had yet to be tested in the courts”. And while acknowledging the “illegality” of the search warrant, both the courts and the DPP’s office were “nonetheless prepared to admit the evidence obtained in the search”.

In the matter of the missing 57 kilos of drugs and firearms stolen from a police evidence locker, which attracted much media and public criticism and was later described by Mr Baines as a possible “inside job” involving “corrupt officers”, who thus far have never been identified the governor stated she was “satisfied that the appropriate remedial action was taken” and therefore the allegation made by Mr Bush, did “not warrant any independent investigation into the Commissioner’s handling of the matter and/or any disciplinary action.”

Responding to what Mr Bush alleged was the increase in the numbers of complaints made against the police since 2009 and Mr Baines’ arrival, the governor provided graph evidence, though failed to identify its source, which showed that contrary to Mr Bush’s claims, complaints against the police actually “dropped from 224 in 2009 to 56 in 2015”, as she dismissed the allegation as “not having any substance”.

Similarly, as it related to the contention that there was inadequate succession planning put in place concerning the police helicopter, Ms Kilpatrick said “whether the complaint of inadequate succession planning is intended as a general complaint or to relate to the helicopter staff only”, the governor described the claim made against Mr Baines as being “insufficiently substantiated”

As it related to the allegations concerning the failure to set up a Police Complaints Authority or the “exorbitant sums” that have been paid out in civil actions, the governor stated unequivocally that this responsibility rests with the Ministry of Home Affairs, which falls under the Premier, Hon Alden McLaughlin and therefore the “Commissioner should not be disciplinarily responsible for.”

As it related to allegations of poor staff management, which included possible discrimination against Caymanian officers that was evidenced by a mass exodus from the RCIPS in 2009-2010, the governor again suggested the facts contradicted the claims.

In her response she stated, “some officers have left the service due to performance issues, whilst others have been actively developed and supported.” The governor went on instead to congratulate the performance of David Baines by stipulating that “since the Commissioner has been in his post, two ‘Caymanian Only’ recruitment classes and pay awards have been secured to address the disparity of salaries between locally recruited and expatriate officers, that arose as a result of the moratorium preventing salary increases”, which again Ms Kilpatrick pointed out, were mandated by the elected representatives and therefore not the actions or lack thereof by the commissioner.

The governor’s response to Mr Bush on 12 of May was copied to the Premier, Hon. Alden McLaughlin, the Deputy Governor, Franz Manderson, Chief Officer for the Ministry of Home Affairs, Eric Bush together with at the time, the Deputy Chief Officer Wesley Howell as well as to Commissioner of Police, David Baines who was scheduled to leave his post on 31 May.

The post Governor responds to complaints on former CoP appeared first on The Cayman Reporter.

In a previous Viewpoint published on this page on 4 May 2016, written after MLAs finally amended the Health Services Authority (HSA) Law to remove the contentious clause granting blanket immunity to HSA doctors, we noted that by not making the change retroactive the government was effectively shutting out the claims of people who have suffered medical negligence and malpractice in the years since the clause was in effect.

This week, we see the real human impact this decision is having – ironically on the very child and family whose case sparked the controversy which led to the change in the first place.

That is the case of Noreen Thompson and her daughter Donnette, who suffered injuries at birth which led to permanent damage. Ms Thompson was attempting to sue the HSA for damages when the judge presiding over her case ruled that the HSA and all of its employees were granted malpractice immunity under the law.

Unfortunately, they remain unable to claim compensation for what Ms Thompson alleges was medical malpractice which caused her daughter’s severe disabilities.

Donnette was diagnosed at birth with Hypoxic Ischaemic Encephalopathy (HIE) and subsequently thereafter developed Spastic Quadriparesis, as well as a Bilateral Brachial Plexus Palsy. As a result of the severe disabilities it is unlikely that Donnette will ever live an independent life.

Donnette, now 10 years old, requires round the clock and specialised care. Government currently pays her family just CI$550 per month towards her care.

This is a mere drop in the bucket, as anyone who has ever had to care for a severely ill or disabled person knows. This is a pittance when it comes to caring for a healthy child, much less one who needs specific care and treatment. All the time. For the rest of her life.

We join with Kent McTaggart and the other concerned volunteers who are spearheading a fundraising campaign for Donnette and her family.

As Mr McTaggart noted on Facebook when he first announced the effort, our legislators failed Donnette by not making provision for her when they amended the law. He also had justifiably harsh words for the rest of us who have done nothing to help, and also for the government agencies and community that have not rallied behind this child and her family.

He said, “What our people, social services, church leaders have allowed to happen to this beautiful soul is a real indication of the ugly indifference we carry inside. Our MLAs took the time to fix the law, they took the praises from the public, but they have all turned their backs to the little girl they failed to protect in the first place.”

Mr McTaggart called on all sitting MLAs to “reach into their pockets and assist this family. Not for a vote, not for any reason other than it is the right thing to do.”

He didn’t only single out the politicians.

He said, “I am also challenging the private sector, all the lawyers, accountants, developers…who make 6 figures, have boats, live on a canal… Do more than the pocket change, change Donnette’s stars, bless her and her mother beyond their wildest dreams. Collectively it can be done if each one of you stroke a check with at least 3 zeros on it.”

He concluded his impassioned plea and challenge by saying, “Donnette and her mom have paid the price of admission, they deserve a bit of what you have. Do the right thing, don’t let the sun set today without making Donnette Thompson’s life vastly better.”

Whether Mr McTaggart’s words reached the hearts of the politicians and the Islands’ wealthy elite, we do not know. But they certainly struck a chord with his fellow Caymanians, some of whom – notably Justin Frazier and Shyvon Hydes, have banded together to create a Go Fund Me account for Donnette and to drum up and collect other donations.

We applaud Mr McTaggart and his wife Michelle, themselves the parents of a special needs child, for taking the time and initiative, and also having the heart to help someone else in need.

Our concern during all of the political posturing that ensued over the law was that the people at the heart of the matter would get lost in the middle. That is the people who may have suffered malpractice or negligence at the hands of HSA medical staff in the years since the law has been in effect. That is 12 long years. Who knows how many cases could have occurred during that substantial time frame? A time in which HSA doctors basically got a free pass.

Premier McLaughlin, said while Government empathised with people who wished to claim medical negligence against HSA personnel prior to the enactment of the law it could not make a policy decision to have the law retroactive as it would leave the HSA “exposed” to litigation without being adequately insured over that intervening period.

We understand that government cannot open itself up to unknown financial risk, but can anyone in all good conscience accept that countless people have no form of redress or of receiving financial assistance for care they may require as the result of HSA negligence?

We find this unacceptable.

The premier said, “We think it is fundamentally wrong that someone who suffered injury from someone who was negligent is debarred from taking their case to court and not seek damages for that injury.”

So isn’t that fundamental wrong still a wrong whether it happens today or occurred 12 years ago?

Once again it seems that it is the people who get lost in the middle of all of this. Real people, like a girl struggling with cerebral palsy and a mother fighting to care for her. Doesn’t their desire for justice and need for assistance count for more than protecting the HSA from financial loss?

At some point, we have to think in terms of morals and justice rather than dollars and cents.

At least in the case of young Donnette and her family, thanks to the efforts of concerned citizens like Mr McTaggart, each of us can help to make a difference, even if our lawmakers chose not to.

Donations are being accepted either directly online at GoFundMe or by contacting Kent McTaggart on 525-2992, or Shyvon Hydes on 929-1979. Please help if you can.

.

The post Morals and justice or dollars and cents? appeared first on The Cayman Reporter.

Bodden Town MLA Alva Suckoo

Bodden Town MLA Alva Suckoo has filed a private member’s motion requesting that the government consider immediately putting plans in place for the completion of a third primary school in his district, which he noted is the fastest growing district in the Cayman Islands.

The motion, which is on the agenda for this sitting of the Legislative Assembly, was seconded by fellow Bodden Town MLA Anthony Eden.

It states that the resources of both Savannah Primary School and Bodden Town Primary School are currently not adequate to meet the primary level education needs of the district.

The PTA of Savannah Primary School has circulated a petition seeking increased resources for the school, which has seen its enrollment figures more than double in the last decade.

This, the Boddent Town MLAs said, proves problematic when the number of primary school students in the district is expected to increase.

Mr Suckoo confirmed that the motion was triggered in part by the Cayman Islands Baseline Inspection of Schools Report of June 2015 which identified numerous issues impacting the academic performance of students between the ages of 5 and 18. These issues included inadequate teaching quality, inadequate staffing levels, poor quality accommodation and resources, poorly prepared and inadequate numbers of teaching assistants, and unprepared and inadequate numbers of special education needs coordinators.

The motion states the resources of both Savannah Primary School and Bodden Town Primary School (pictured) are currently not adequate to meet the primary level education needs of the district.

“I’ve been aware of the concerns in both schools for several years and the baseline inspection report of 2015 confirmed what I was hearing from concerned teachers and parents,” he told The Cayman Reporter.

The motion states that the report made substantial specific recommendations to address the issues it highlighted, which it says for the most part, have not been implemented.

It further states the country’s top priority must be the provision of educational facilities, programmes and resources that meet the increasing and changing needs of its young people.

Mr Suckoo noted that the government owns property in the district of Bodden Town suitable for the construction of the proposed primary education facility.

“The location (of the school) will be determined by the catchment requirements. The fastest growing and most populous areas will probably benefit most from the new school,” he said.

The motion also requests that the government complete the primary school no later than June 2018.

When asked about the estimated cost of the project Mr Suckoo said, “I don’t have proper cost estimates so I don’t want to throw figures out there. But based on Clifton Hunter’s costs we can assume around the region of $30 million maximum.”

The motion, as an emergency measure, also calls for the government to immediately put in place the policies and make the appropriations required in order to address the issues raised by, and follow the recommendations contained in, the 2015 report.

Mr Suckoo stated, “Those are the priority for Bodden Town and the school is a longer term solution to the rapid population increase in the district.”

“Because this budget will span 18 months I see this as this administration’s last opportunity to address the issues,” he added.

The motion comes in the wake of the launch of a petition by the Parent Teacher Association (PTA) at Savannah Primary School demanding that the Ministry of Education address any deficiencies at the school.

A year ago the Baseline Inspection report gave the school a failing grade. However, the Ministry of Education has not taken any apparent action to provide adequate staffing and resources at the fast-growing school, say concerned parents.

As a result, parents of the primary school, following a meeting of the PTA Executive Council on 20 May, have taken their need for resources into their own hands in the form of a petition.

The petition is presently circulating in the public domain seeking to force Ministry of Education officials to take notice and take action.

The post Suckoo seeks new primary school for Bodden Town district appeared first on The Cayman Reporter.

Representatives of the Cayman Islands Government and Dart Realty at the signing of the Third Amendment to the NRA Agreement.

The Cayman Islands Government, the National Roads Authority (NRA) and Dart Realty

signed the Third Amendment to the NRA Agreement on Monday 30 May.

The NRA agreement is billed in a Dart Realty press release as “an economic stimulus package that has created employment opportunities, road infrastructure and sustainable development projects valued at more than US $800 million.”

“This marks a major milestone in a six-year process between Government and Dart Realty,” said Chief Executive Officer Mark VanDevelde. “What began as conversations on how to stimulate the economy during the global economic crisis evolved into an innovative agreement to create road infrastructure and incentivise our long term development activity in the Cayman Islands.”

Dart Realty Chief Operating Officer Jackie Doak and Premier Hon Alden McLaughlin

The NRA Agreement, executed in December 2011, included the extension of the Esterley Tibbetts Highway to West Bay, the redevelopment of the Courtyard Marriott hotel which had been closed since 2008 and the legal closure of a section West Bay Road.

A subsequent amendment added an expansion and improvement of Public Beach along with land, a network of biking and walking trails and US $5 million for community programmes.

When the hotel redeveloped as Kimpton Seafire Resort + Spa welcomes its first guests in November 2016, these projects will represent more than US $350 million in direct investment. More than 775 construction workers are at the Kimpton site each day as the hotel nears completion.

The Dart Realty press release said, “From the commencement of the initial NRA Agreement projects in January 2012, Dart Realty’s development initiatives have provided more than 3.1 million hours of work or the equivalent of 344 continuous, full-time jobs over a period of more than four years.”

In February 2015, Dart Realty and the Cayman Islands Government announced consensus on a Third Amendment to the NRA Agreement which eliminated the 50 per cent tourism tax rebate that has been agreed to by the previous administration.

Under the amended Agreement, Dart Realty will receive an increase in the development duty waiver cap already in place through the NRA Agreement, as well as other duty abatements and waivers related to Dart’s development over the next 30 years.

Also as part of the Third Amendment, Dart Realty committed to investing a further US $400 million in development activity including the realignment and expansion of the Esterley Tibbetts from the Century21 Roundabout through Camana Bay to the Butterfield Roundabout.

The Third Amendment also provides for a legal mechanism that will allow development on an elevated plane over the realigned Esterley Tibbetts Highway as well as a provision for Dart Realty to purchase the freehold title to the former Safehaven lands, which include the North Sound Golf Club.

Most recently Dart Realty and the NRA agreed upon a pedestrian link now under construction south of the Camana Bay Town Centre that will facilitate safe passage beneath the Esterley Tibbetts Highway.

This link will allow the public to walk or cycle from Camana Bay and Cayman International School to the National Gallery and the Harquail Theatre as well as the sports facilities being planned on the west side of the road.

“Our working relationship with the Cayman Islands Government and the National Roads Authority has proven to be positive throughout the process, characterised by collaboration to achieve the goal of continued economic stimulus,” said Chief Operating Officer Jackie Doak. “In addition to fulfilling our commitments under the NRA Agreement, we are moving ahead with diverse development projects which reflect and reinforce our confidence in the ongoing growth and prosperity of the Cayman Islands.”

The post Third Amendment to NRA Agreement executed appeared first on The Cayman Reporter.